Showing posts with label Hill Climbing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hill Climbing. Show all posts

Saturday, March 3, 2007

The View Never Changes

My new bike is on the way. Fast Freddy says that it will be like adding another 200 hp to my car (of course he doesn't realize my car only has 100 hp to start with). I sure hope he's right because if todays ride is any indication, I'm gonna need all the help I can get.

This was the first club ride of the year, and my first real road ride for the year-30 miles, lots of hills. I took the EZ-1. Here is the view I saw on most of the hills. Well the uphills anyway.

In addition to just being totally under prepared for this much ride, I think that the other biggest problem was the forecast of 38 degrees with rain. The sane people stayed home. Luckily the rain held off until were back in town.

Early in the ride I was totally discouraged and disgusted. As the day went on, I realized that I was holding on fairly well on the steeper climbs (like the one ahead here)-not really any different than I would have expected on the Rambouillet this early in the season. Where I was really dragging was on the gentler grades. On the flat or downhills I was well toward the front.

I'm still discouraged, but realize:

1. I would have been perfectly happy with my riding if I were alone, or with more compatible riders. I didn't feel the least bit slow except when I saw the pack pulling away from me. I do hate being the slowest person on the ride.

2. I did fairly well with the one thing I'd been working on this winter-steep hills. I dropped back on these, but always have with this group regardless of the bike I'm on. The problem came in when there was a long run up to the hill, like in the photo where I was already well off the back before it got steep.

3. I was not hoovering. I even felt pretty good at the top of the mile long 12 percent grade. I think I was only badly winded one time and was pushing fairly hard on that hill (the one in the picture). It was my legs not my lungs that were limiting my speed on the slight up grades. I hope that concentrating on that type of situation will make a difference. I think this might be indicative of what some people say about climbing on recumbents, that you can't bring in your upper body like on an upright (using more muscles). You aerobic fitness is the real limit though, and it's easier to build up leg muscles than aerobic level.

4. I really have very few miles on this year. I've been riding the steep hills around my neighborhood, but not much distance (because of the weather).

5. I suppose the new bike might help. Most people say that it will make a big difference. I hope they're right.

Sunday, February 11, 2007

Ditto.

It's weird. Yesterday I ventured up a street that I hadn't ridden in 20 years. I used to live here at the top of Linden Street, just off the left side of the photo. I go by this street on almost all of these neighborhood rides I've been doing lately, but think I'd blocked the street out since I'd decided I didn't feel safe riding up it (except maybe on a mt. bike).

The street is steep (something a bit over 20 percent); it is also narrow, and the surface isn't great. It's odd that it doesn't look all that steep here; it sure does from the bottom. This is the steepest pitch, right at the end. That last time I rode up here my chain skipped on the freewheel and I did a face plant right about at this spot. It hurt.

Yesterday I was riding by on the EZ-1 just one block down the hill and realized that even if I couldn't make it up I could probably get my feet down, and even if I didn't I'd be close to the ground and would hit something a lot less vulnerable than my face. I know that seems sort of obvious, but it is a bit of a breakthrough for me, realizing that it probably won't hurt (literally) to try.

I could just get up it (and was only doing this last block). I didn't have any particular problem, but it just seems right at the limit of what I can pedal with my 23 inch low gear. The front wheel starts to get light on the EZ-1, but I'm leaning forward a bit anyway and it's not too bad.

I was very pleased to have ridden it, not so much because it was difficult (which it always is), but I guess because it was like making up with an old friend you'd fallen out with.

This is one street that I thought I'd never attempt on the Burley (or any bike with a higher BB). I did go back today to check the grade since from the top it looked like the end of the lower block is actually steeper (it isn't, but click the picture for a bigger view to see what I mean). I was able to get up that lower block just fine on the Burley since the street is wider and the surface better there. I was totally whupped after just that one block so detoured around a little, but finally felt compelled to give the top block a try. It was fine too, well I made it up anyway.

I would have sworn to you just yesterday that I could not ride that street on a higher BB bike. It is certainly less spooky to take on a street like this with the low pedals on the EZ-1, but once again, as far as difficulty goes, the cushier seat back on the Burley seemed like the biggest difference between the bikes. I've become a real fan of the Cobra style rigid seat, and will tell you some of the other things I like about it later (and a fix for one of the things I don't like).

So for now, what I said Feb 9, the bike isn't making much difference on these steep streets (other than handling); I'm still having to turn the pedals over all by myself. I expect much bigger difference when the weather breaks and I can get out for some faster, but hilly, rides. Of course I was wrong yesterday, so I'll just have to wait and give it a try. It can't hurt (much).

Friday, February 9, 2007

It's Not the Bike, or maybe it is...


One of the things that continues to baffle me is just how much difference the bike makes in getting up a hill. Stories and comparisons abound, but it's hard to really nail anything down.

I'd thought for some time that my Easy Racers EZ-1 (not the Sun-made bike) climbs a little better than my Burley Canto, but I'm just not so sure of that anymore, at least as regards really steep hills.

I've been playing around on this short, but quite steep, Wabash Street over the past week, riding it a couple different days on each of the two bikes. The first day I was out on the Canto. I was a little surprised to make it up and thought that it will be a piece of cake on the EZ-1. Actually it feels about the same on both. I'm down to walking speed on either and can turn the pedals over okay, but don't have much left over.

Here are the few things I am pretty sure of:

The seat back makes a heck of a difference. My EZ-1 has the original, very rigid-backed Cobra style seat. It is a really solid support when you are down to mashing the pedals instead of spinning. The first ride I took on my Burley, I could hardly get up steep hills at all, the seat back was so flexy. The speed struts really helped, and it also makes a big difference keeping the seat back mesh tightened up. You'd have to have a pretty whippy bike for the frame to flex as much as some recumbent seat backs do (the frame on my old Infinity probably did flex that much). And I don't think as much of this seat flex gets returned to the pedals as it does with frame flex. The comfortable seat back materials in particular seem to just soak up power without giving it back.

Handling makes a big difference too when the going gets slow. The EZ-1 is hard to beat at that point. It's hard to imagine an easier to handle bike on a really steep pitch, plus it sure is nice to have your feet close to the ground. The Burley converts from LWB to SWB and handles fine both ways. I actually prefer the long wheelbase for really steep climbs since there is no chance of your feet hitting the tire. In the LWB mode the bottom bracket it also just a touch lower and the seat just a bit less reclined. Not a big difference, but I slightly prefer that too on steep hills. On the very steepest grades that I encounter, neither bike suits me perfectly. The front wheel gets light on the EZ-1 (I have the seat pretty far back), and the handling and higher bottom bracket start to be a handful on the Burley.

Both frames seem plenty stiff and I just don't see how I could be losing much energy there.

Obviously, really low gears can be great. The Rans V-Rex I rode for while had a 3 speed rear hub, plus the 21 speed derailleur gears. You could really pedal up anything that you could keep the bike upright on with that setup. Both of my current bikes could stand a touch lower gearing.

Many people spend a fortune to shave a few ounces off their bikes, but it just doesn't seem like a big deal to me-at least not a few pounds difference. Neither of my bikes is light. My EZ-1 is a lot lighter than the Sun made EZ-1 SC (a bit lighter even than their aluminum version). The Burley probably weighs quite a bit more, but I don't really know. A light bike has a great responsive feel when climbing, but you are still carrying the whole load up the hill.

There are online calculators that will show you how much time you gain or lose with weight, and it isn't all that much for small changes. Bike weight doesn't even come into the calculation, just total weight. The lighter you are the more difference a couple pounds will make to the GVW (gross vehicular weight--very gross in the case of some of us).

Lots of other things probably do matter, like body angle to the pedals, but I really haven't got a grasp on them yet. I'm always anxious to hear from people who have explored this sort of thing. I'm still ready, even anxious, to believe in some bike magic for hill climbing; I just haven't found it yet.

Thursday, February 1, 2007

More Gears Stuff

I think I left the impression with yesterday's post that I really didn't get much out of my messing around experiment with bigger gears. Really, I think trying something different like this is pretty useful.

Now I know what it feels like to be in one gear higher than is really practical for me on a hill. If I get to that same feel with my lowest gear I'll know about what I need to do about it. I know that on the Sixth Street hill that kicked my butt a couple days ago it felt about as hard to push the pedals as it did trying to get up Jefferson Street in the middle ring did yesterday (I could probably do it but might hurt myself trying). So if I look at the percentages to the other gears I've used on Jefferson Street, then I can make a good guess that I could make it up Sixth Street okay with a 19.5" gear, but it would take a 17" gear to make it comfortable.

Of course there are a lot of variables, but now I've got pretty good idea of what I need. Happily, that agrees closely with what my intuition said. I'd been hoping to get my low to around 18.5 to 19.5. The problem of course is that to get the change I want I would need to go from my 32T rear cog to a 40T to get to about a 19" gear. Things are a little better on the front where going from my 30T ring (standard road triple) to a 24T would get me to the same place. Handily, 24T is the smallest ring that most road and touring triples will take. So I'm good to go. Well, shifting might be worse, but should be okay with grip shifters or bar-end shifters. A 34T rear combined with the 24T front would even get me to about 18 gear inches, but on my 8 speed rear I prefer the 32T cassette. If you have a 700C rear wheel you're going to need that 34T rear to get down to 19 gear inches.

I'm using a simple spreadsheet to play with these gear variables, but there are plenty of good gear inch calculators on the web.

Wednesday, January 31, 2007

Gears To Ya'

It's another chilly day in Morgantown, but the streets are mostly clear at least. That's Jefferson Street straight below in the photo and it's sure in better shape than yesterday.

I got myself signed up for the BROL forum inspired by this thread on gearing, but haven't posted yet. The emphasis of the thread is on low gears, and I was pleasantly surprised at the number of people willing to give up some high end for a real stump-pulling low. It seems like all I usually here about is bigger and bigger gears.

I've got lots of chainrings and cranks laying around and have been anxious to experiment with a bit lower gears, but it has been just too darned cold to work in my unheated garage. So, in the spirit of experimentation, I went the other way and tried some of my usual hills in the middle ring on my Canto. That gives a low of about 33.5 gear inches as opposed to about 24" in the small ring.

Well, that was fun for a few minutes. Hills that I could hit with a bit of steam were fast and easy-if they weren't too long, but I bailed out before I got as far up Jefferson Street as you see in the picture here-where it tops 16 percent (I did make it as far as the slippery picture at the end of yesterday's post). At that point a tiny bit of common sense trickled in and I tried one cog up in the back with the granny ring in front (about 27.5" gear). That was just doable, and I finished the ride without needing (well, without using) the lowest gear. I didn't go up Theresa Drive which hits 20 percent, and I would not bother trying; I like my knees to much.

What did I learn? Maybe not a whole lot, but it took my mind off of the cold :-)

Lower gears are bound to be more fun.

Friday, January 26, 2007

A Few Hillclimbing Tips

Hopefully, I'll have a lot more tips from a variety of sources in the future, but we might as well start off with a few things I've noticed that are helping me get up my steep neighborhood hills on my recumbents.

1. Riding Postion seems to play a big role in getting power efficiently to the pedals. I have two recumbents at this time, an original, EZ-1 made in Freedom, CA (thanks Nick!) and a Burley Canto (convertible S or LWB).

I recently decided that I had the seat on my EZ-1 considerably too far back and am amazed at the improvement moving it forward made (heel just touches the pedal at full extension now). There are people who can just look at you on the bike and know exactly what needs to be done. I understand that the late Gardner Martin was a master of this and I suspect that Larry Black, Peter Stull, and others can do it to. Seek out and take the advice of experts like these if you have the opportunity, otherwise keep an open mind to small changes that might add up to a difference-leg extension, seat angle, bar height and angle.

2. Check your seat back for tautness. I found that the mesh on my Burley's seat had loosened up considerably and I could really feel it soaking up my pushes on steeper hills. Spinning can largely alleviate this issue, but is not always posible.

3. Pushing against the seat back for more power is certainly one of the advantages of a recumbent bicycle, but the higher you put the pressure on the seat back, the more likely a portion of your energy is going into flexing the seat. I'm finding that putting my force toward the bottom of the seat back makes for a more solid platform to push from. This seems to help even with the very rigid Cobra style seat on my EZ-1.

4. Handlebars. This is the one I still understand the least, but I feel something useful so I'll put out some tentative thoughts. I'm finding that on the steepest grades (over 16 percent) I feel more powerful hunching forward a tiny bit, probably not even enough that you would see it. This is really very similar to what I was mentioning in #3 about focussing your force farther down on the seat back, but it still feels like a bit of something else is going on. I'm using the bars when doing this, but not putting much real force on them (you really can't pull hard on most recumbent bars). Just a slight pulling forward and focussing your pressure from the base of the seat back down your legs. Maybe someone will have some ideas of what is going with this, but I only know that I feel like I'm getting a little extra power. This is probably not a technique for places where you could be spinning. Fast Freddy Markham had some rider position pictures and discussion on the Easy Racers Forum, but they seem to be updating their website and the forums don't seem to be available right now.

Update-I thought some more about this today and do think that there is more going on than just a more solid spot to push from (the base of the seat back). Also, I think I'm understanding the roll of the handlebars a little better. I don't think that this slight hunching forward would work as well with USS (underseat steering); I think the handlebars are providing something to balance on (not the right word, but as close as I can get right now).

5. Spinning is certainly the way to go where you can do it. I want to work on this more when we get some warmer weather here and I'm willing to go farther from home. I do hit a grade somewhere around 14 percent where anything remotely resembling spinning circles is only a memory and that is the type of climbing I've been working with lately.

I hope you find something useful in these ideas.